Master Feedback Today. Avoid Defensive Reactions…
We’ve all been there. One thoughtless comment, one badly worded critique—and boom, it sticks with you for years.
You know what I’m talking about. You can recall the nasty nicknames you were called back in grade school several years ago.
My nickname was “fatty” because I was overweight and uncoordinated. As a result, I was never picked to be on anyone’s team during recess.
Despite the fact I’ve been in great shape for years, hiking around the world, going to the gym, have a trainer, and eat right, that nickname still makes me reluctant to ever join a competitive sport. Words matter.
Chances are you can still remember a poorly worded comment made on a performance review ten years ago. Your boss said, “Overall you’ve done a real good job, BUT…” And to this day, all you remember is the “BUT” and the negative words that followed.
Here’s the thing: Negative criticism has a long shelf life. And when it’s dished out carelessly, it doesn’t just sting—it drains motivation and chips away at someone’s spirit.
The good news? There’s a better way. You can give feedback that’s honest and constructive—without leaving emotional bruises. All it takes is a quick check through six simple filters. These questions take just seconds to consider and they’ll help you deliver feedback that people can hear, accept, and act on—without going into defense mode.
Let’s dive into those six filters.
►1. Is This the Right Time?
Timing isn’t everything—but it’s pretty darn close.
Just because you’re ready to vent doesn’t mean the other person is ready to hear it. Forget the whole “get it off your chest” mindset. That’s about your comfort, not theirs.
Instead, check in: “Hey, is now a good time to talk?” You might find they’re already overwhelmed. Maybe they had a rough morning—flat tire, coffee spill, crashed laptop—and your feedback is just one more punch they don’t need.
Wait for a better moment. Don’t delay forever, but be considerate. A calm conversation is way more productive than a defensive one.
► 2. Am I Doing This to Help or to Hurt?
Your intentions matter. A lot.
Ask yourself: “Am I giving this feedback to truly help the other person grow, or am I just irritated and looking to unload?”
People can tell the difference. When feedback comes from a place of caring—when they know you’re rooting for their success—it lands much better.
I’ll never forget one of my early mentors, Professor. Don Nelson. He gave me tough feedback constantly—pages of it, in fact. But I never got defensive. Why? Because I knew he was invested in my growth. He wanted me to succeed. That made all the difference.
I’m also invested in YOUR GROWTH. I’ll do everything I can to make sure you succeed with my 3-session master class on THE TRUST CONNECTION: How To Build Stronger, Empathic, Engaged Relationships. We meet on May 22, May 29, and June 5 2025 from 9 am to 12 noon Eastern Time (8 am CT, 7 am MT, 6 am PT).
Click here for more information and/or register.
Just because you’re ready to vent doesn’t mean the other person is ready to hear it. Forget the whole “get it off your chest” mindset. That’s about your comfort, not theirs
Instead, check in: “Hey, is now a good time to talk?” You might find they’re already overwhelmed. Maybe they had a rough morning—flat tire, coffee spill, crashed laptop—and your feedback is just one more punch they don’t need.
Wait for a better moment. Don’t delay forever, but be considerate. A calm conversation is way more productive than a defensive one.
► 3. Is My Feedback Fresh?
Feedback loses power when it’s stale.
No one wants to hear, “Remember that thing you did three months ago? Yeah, that was bad.” By then, details are fuzzy and defensiveness kicks in. The other person is likely to think, “That’s not how I remember it.”
Take a cue from the TSA: “If you see something, say something.” The sooner, the better—as long as the timing is right (see filter #1).
Say something like: “Hey, I noticed the project wasn’t wrapped up by the deadline today—let’s talk about that.” That’s clear and specific. No debates over fuzzy memories.
► 4. Can the Person Actually Change This?
This one’s big.
Before you jump in with “constructive criticism,” ask yourself: “Is this something they can realistically change?” Sometimes yes. Sometimes no.
It’s easy to assume that the other person could change if they really wanted to. That’s not always the case.
Life is more complicated than that. The other person may be under-trained, overwhelmed, or dealing with challenges you don’t see.
My point? Don’t assume malice when it might be circumstance.
That doesn’t mean you overlook or excuse poor performance or bad behavior. Team and families don’t work if you allow that to continue.
But it does mean that you deal with the other person’s behavior using the approach that best fits the situation. One person may need more job training, another one some stress reduction, and still another a strong come-to-Jesus discussion.
► 5. Are You Inviting Dialogue?
Feedback isn’t a one-way street. Don’t just drop a critique and walk away. If the other person has no input or say in the matter, they’ll feel powerless—and probably defensive.
After you share your feedback, invite theirs. Ask:
“How does that sound to you?”
“What do you think happened there?”
“How can we move forward together?”
Engaging the other person in the process not only diffuses tension—it builds commitment. When they help shape the solution, they’re much more likely to follow through.
► 6. Do They Need Criticism or Encouragement?
This is where leadership becomes an art.
Sometimes, people genuinely need redirection. That’s where corrective feedback comes in—it highlights what’s not working and how to fix it.
Other times, people are doing okay—they just need encouragement to do even better. That’s where praise becomes a powerful tool.
So, ask yourself: “Will a well-placed compliment do more to improve this situation than a critique?”
Either route—criticism or praise—can lead to positive change. The key is choosing the one that works best for this person in this moment.
Final Thoughts: Be Corrective, Not Just Critical
Benjamin Disraeli, the British Prime Minister, once said, “It is much easier to be critical than to be correct.”
Effective communication and leadership is about being correct. That means thinking before speaking. It means caring enough to deliver feedback with respect, clarity, and compassion.
When you run your feedback through these six filters, you don’t just avoid defensiveness—you spark growth. You build trust. And you create relationships that get better, together.
|
